The stories contained in *Ash and Crayons* are important. This is undeniable, especially as the Russian invasion of Ukraine continues, with no sign that the aggression will cease. Director Evgeny Afineevsky—who has previously documented Ukraine’s recent history—focuses here on the impact of the war on children. It is devastating to hear what both teenagers and young children have had to endure—not only in recent years, since the latest hostilities by Russia began, but going back nearly a decade to the occupation of Crimea.
Of course, the problem with Afineevsky’s documentary does not lie in these stories themselves. Hearing them directly from the protagonists—seven children of various ages who have survived missile attacks, captivity, and other horrors—is the best, and perhaps the only, way for the filmmaker to convey what has happened and what continues to unfold. Yet, the fact that the film fails to achieve its ultimate goal speaks to the magnitude of the miscalculations the director has made in other aspects of the work.
Director: Evgeny Afineevsky
Stars: Vladyslav Buriak, Pope Francis, Saad Kassis-Mohamed
Afineevsky’s approach involves dramatizing the accounts of these children—some of whom, by now, are technically adults. To do this, the filmmaker collaborated with several animation studios in Ukraine. Their work is, without a doubt, impressive; the animation teams do not shy away from depicting the rawest details of these accounts. There is a common misconception that animation is a medium intended exclusively or primarily for children; while the director’s decision to use it to narrate the experiences of real children may have stemmed from that belief, the animators themselves effectively dispel such a notion.
The question, however, is whether a stylistic choice of this kind is appropriate for addressing a subject such as this. To be clear, the animation studios that worked on the film go to great lengths to imbue it with realism—employing, for instance, clear rotoscoping techniques for human movement in certain segments—and to depict, as faithfully as possible, the bloody aftermath of a surprise attack on residential areas and other locations that, in any war, should remain outside the scope of military targets.
However, these sequences do not make up the entirety of the film. A large portion of it incorporates recorded interviews with the protagonists, as well as home videos, archival news footage, and other types of material, allowing us to see these children both as they were and as they are today. It is striking to observe real people and authentic footage—including images of events and their aftermath, which are subsequently recreated through animation—and to see how, suddenly, everything transforms into something inherently unreal. This juxtaposition creates an immediate distance between what we hear (directly from the children themselves) or see (through the real-life footage) and what the animators have created—regardless of how compelling or unsettling the content of those segments may be.
It is not as though the children whose stories form the narrative inspired this creative choice. While it is true that some of them—such as 8-year-old Roman Oleksiv or 7-year-old Sasha Pascal—show certain artistic inclinations (the former took up ballroom dancing after surviving an attack on a hospital, while the latter practiced rhythmic gymnastics both before and after losing her left leg in a missile strike on the residential complex where she was staying with her family), this does not mean they were the impetus for the film’s stylistic approach. On the other hand, the stories of other young people—such as Bohdan Yermohin, who was 18 at the time of his interview, and 14-year-old Veronika Vlasova, both of whom were held against their will by Russian officials (and they are not the only such cases featured in the film)—are so harrowing that their extracurricular activities are likely the last thing on one’s mind when listening to their accounts.
In other words, the animation comes across as an empty device—a mere gimmick intended to capture the viewer’s attention. The fact that this narrative tool—a scrapbook filled with diary entries, drawings, and photographs—appears to have been generated by an artificial intelligence program suggests that Afineevsky did not make this choice with full conviction or as part of a coherent plan. The film’s overall structure is also somewhat chaotic. Some of the children’s stories seem complete, only for them to reappear later after a long absence, while in the meantime, other stories have been told from beginning to end.

Comments
Post a Comment