Making a mixtape for someone is a pretty bold move. You might like that person. You might even think you’re in love with them. But giving them a mixtape—out of all the possible things—is, in a way, tantamount to saying: "Here is a collection of emotions I’ve decided you ought to feel, in an order I’ve determined myself, and for reasons probably no one but me will understand. Enjoy!" That’s quite a statement.
The ninth installment in the beloved *V/H/S* franchise takes that potentially awkward premise to a terrifying cinematic extreme; the new anthology premieres on Shudder on October 9. This time around, the evening’s entertainment includes four short films and several musical interludes, all centered around the theme of... sound? It is, without a doubt, a perfectly valid excuse to shoot another *V/H/S* movie. However, *V/H/S Mixtape* also suggests that maintaining the saga’s novelty factor is becoming increasingly difficult.
Directors: Ernest Dickerson, Flying Lotus, Tobias Forge
Writers: Zoe Cooper, Ernest Dickerson, Matt Landsman
Stars: Mike Ferguson, Omar Mustafa Adem, Sarah Berman
Generally speaking, the element of surprise goes hand in hand with the found-footage genre. *V/H/S* returned in 2021 after a seven-year hiatus following the franchise’s critical low point: *V/H/S: Viral*. Today, the team behind the brand is a mix of veteran producers and newcomers who have kept the fanbase alive by using the franchise as a platform for filmmakers with a remarkably diverse range of creative talents.
In *V/H/S Mixtape* (the first installment released under the franchise’s new owners, Spooky Pictures and Image Nation Abu Dhabi), the participating artists are also at very different stages of their careers. Veteran director and Spike Lee collaborator Ernest Dickerson brings decades of filmmaking experience, while French horror director David Moreau arrives fresh off the success of *MadS* (2024). RZA (of Wu-Tang Clan) and electronic musician Flying Lotus also lend their unique sensibilities, joining Tobias Forge—frontman of the band Ghost—who makes his directorial debut.
Yet, it is up-and-coming animator Renee Zhan who best demonstrates the franchise's continued relevance as a showcase for unconventional horror talent. The boundaries of contemporary "found footage" are increasingly blurred, and there is no denying that a vertical video suddenly appearing in someone’s feed can deceive the viewer in ways a feature film cannot. In this increasingly unpredictable digital landscape, Zhan’s contribution, *Dance, Dance, Dance, Dance*, is all the more impressive for embracing a decidedly old-school broadcast format: the children’s puppet show.
Featuring original creations from Jim Henson’s Creature Shop, a brief behind-the-scenes glimpse of the long-cancelled children’s show *Curious Chorus* reveals a deliciously cruel satire of Hollywood greed. Barbara Crampton (long live the queen!) plays a studio executive with the manic confidence of a coke-fueled Suze Orman, overseeing a misguided attempt to recreate beloved characters using digital scans.
The premise kicks off with some vaguely irritating commentary on the death of linear television before plunging into a first-person chase sequence reminiscent of a ride through the haunted Tunnel of Love at an insane amusement park. Screenwriter Zoe Cooper provides a total of four potential victims for Zhan to dispatch; the puppets quickly eliminate the first three in inventive and entertaining ways. The fourth "sack of meat" does not fare as well, facing a slow, agonizing death that is not only uncomfortable to endure but strangely embarrassing to witness.
From the recent theatrical horror hit *Buddy* to the surreal Showtime series *Kidding*, a surprising number of genre productions have succeeded by turning adorable felt puppets into vessels for something truly twisted. What sets "Dance, Dance, Dance, Dance" apart is its extraordinary command of the inevitable, achieving its impact through the brutal deliberation with which the torture is carried out. The segment’s theme song—instantly grating—lodges itself in your brain like a catchy tune you’d love to shake off while watching someone else lose their mind; yet, much like an unwanted playlist from a secret admirer, this short-form nightmare insists you pay attention to what Zhan has in store for you, whether you like it or not.
The rest of *V/H/S Mixtape* lacks that agility, making the final result largely disappointing.
For his part, Moreau contributes "Heartbeat," in which elements reminiscent of *The Descent* and *The Backrooms* star in an absurd horror duet.
Dickerson’s "The Music of Mr. Sze" proves infinitely more frustrating, as the esteemed cinematographer brings an excessive level of visual sophistication to a boarding-house mystery centered on a string musician and a young man wearing smart glasses. The moment these two elements converge, it is clear we are lost, and one cannot help but wonder what might have happened had someone else written Dickerson’s contribution to *V/H/S*. That said, there is something about being held captive by another person’s questionable taste that can work very well in certain horror anthologies, and the director, at least, shows a wonderfully playful side here.
Finally, RZA’s "Death Tone" fares somewhat better than the previous two segments, though it feels like a low-budget mashup of *High Fidelity* and *American Mary*. Neela Jolene plays a young sound engineer mourning the death of her father—a recording artist—while striving for her own legendary success on stage. Unfortunately, her father’s musical achievements relied on deeply perverse methods, and she must find her own path in the family business, regardless of what the critics say.
Apparently inspired by the sound of a dental drill that Billie Eilish used in her hit track "Bury a Friend," "Death Tone" features a fantastic sequence in which Jolene’s character remixes literal agony into an aggressive, beat-driven track. The actress is hugely entertaining, and the premise cries out for an explosive, music-video-style finale. However, the ensuing chain of events stumbles awkwardly from one encounter to the next, resulting in a fragmented piece that should have been more ambitious—and ended sooner.
As for the host, shock-metal icons GWAR make appearances throughout the film. This will likely elicit either affection or immediate exhaustion, depending on one's sympathy for this group, infamous for its revolting performances. As a collection of crude and disgusting brutes, GWAR offers objectively funny scatological dialogue, but their segments on "V/H/S Mixtape" are presented with such a cheap visual aesthetic that it makes the band's entire proposition seem dated in the worst possible way. After more than four decades of doing the same damn thing, GWAR continues to age alongside its achievements, fitting them like a sweaty T-shirt. Typically, the narrative thread of a great anthology should give the audience room to breathe, or else make the whole film gradually claustrophobic. GWAR's interludes attempt both and fail at neither, while Forge's contribution is surprisingly forgettable.
Flying Lotus, on the other hand, offers a monstrous, moonlit, animated interlude that is beautiful and barely bothers to fit the theme. Ultimately, it doesn't need to, though one wonders why the filmmaker didn't try something stranger after making films like "Kuso." Of course, by now, that unevenness is an intrinsic part of the "V/H/S" saga's DNA. Originally conceived by Brad Miska—co-founder of Bloody Disgusting—this anthology series has survived a succession of distributors, an explosive resurgence in the streaming era, and, more recently, the addition of a new financial partner.

Comments
Post a Comment