*Below* is overloaded. So overloaded that it naturally conveys a sense of exhaustion; it is as if the effort of juggling its various plotlines has left it breathless.
Nowadays, many journalists complain—rightly so—about being required to perform tasks beyond their core duties or meet unrealistic targets. They do not simply investigate, gather information, and write a report or article for a newspaper or website; they must also master SEO, video editing, social media, and tools like Canva. To make matters worse, they are expected to pitch and write ten articles a day, on top of handling editorial tasks assigned by their superiors.
Creator: Jesse McKeown
Stars: Josh Hartnett, Mackenzie Davis, Charlie Heaton
It is no wonder that many suffer from burnout and even leave the profession due to paltry wages. A corpse or a zombie would likely radiate more vitality than these exhausted journalists forced to multitask. If *Below*—created by Jesse McKeown—were a person working in a newsroom, it, too, would look like one of those burnt-out journalists. After all, this poor creature is expected to be a monster thriller, a love story, a family drama, a tale of sibling rivalry, a sci-fi mystery, a cult horror story, and a plot about a corrupt, greedy businessman all at once.
As you may have gathered, *Below* is overloaded. So overloaded that it naturally conveys a sense of exhaustion; it is as if the effort of juggling its various plotlines has left it breathless. That sense of fatigue is palpable in both its lackluster tone and its mechanical pacing, which jumps from one element to the next in a routine, uninspiring fashion. McKeown’s strategy feels all too familiar in this era of disposable streaming content: throwing everything at the wall without stopping to see what sticks, or tossing every ingredient into the pot without caring if the resulting dish will actually taste good.
In short: if *Below* were a job applicant I had to interview, I wouldn’t even bother asking about things like character development—because the series features no real characters, only mere puppets serving the script’s dictates. Given *Below*’s chaotic and clumsy nature, I doubt its creators even had anything resembling a script before filming began. The gears of the—ahem—story turn on this logic: let’s keep things "fresh" and "unpredictable" with random twists.
Oh, you think *Below* is about a sea monster? Ta-da! Here’s Wade Penney (Charlie Heaton) having supernatural nightmares. Is he hallucinating? Is he actually seeing ghosts and spirits? Nope! That unsettling woman is alive and living on an island with her family. Hey, Jay (Rohan Campbell) owes $80,000 to... someone. Is he in serious danger? Should we be worried about him? Oh, look, those two guys are giving him a brutal beating. Ha, fooled you again! Why do we have a sea monster in this series? Turn one of them into giant squid food and—quick—have the other befriend Jay right before killing off the guy who was the villain a moment ago. Narrative convenience, darling. Oh, sorry. Slip of the tongue. Unpredictable storytelling, darling.
Well, there is a difference between being unpredictable and being clumsy. *Below* not only falls into this latter category, but its "unpredictability" is more akin to rolling dice or drawing slips of paper from a hat to decide the plot's direction after a certain point.
One also gets the impression that McKeown and his team kept telling themselves there are no bad ideas and that everyone should feel free to contribute to the story; they would then simply gather all the suggestions and ideas without bothering to filter or properly develop them. Why does Jay sleep with Jan (Natasha Henstridge)? Why does a sinister-looking woman steal a diamond ring? None of this adds anything of value. But just wait for the final twist. It transforms the very nature of the killer squid, turning it into a figure that embodies both maternal fury and warmth—only to lead to a falsely tragic conclusion that, given the series' mechanical, impersonal, and unoriginal nature, isn't tragic in the slightest.
Perhaps McKeown could have taken a cue from Wade’s personality and made the series something entertainingly weird and ridiculously eccentric. There is nothing wrong with being openly bizarre and "trashy"; if done skillfully, self-deprecation and humor can also be entertaining. However, McKeown seems lost; he doesn't know what he really wants *Below* to be.

Comments
Post a Comment