Rensil D'Silva shows a greater affinity for monotony than for his own story or characters. It is hardly surprising, then, that *Shaque* turns out to be so tedious.
At the heart of *Shaque: Trust No One* lies the potential for a solid psychological thriller about a mother whose newborn is kidnapped—an ordeal that causes her to lose her grip on reality under extreme mental stress. To make matters worse, she is surrounded by a deceitful best friend, a backward-thinking mother-in-law, and an unfaithful husband. All the ingredients for social commentary and the exploration of subjective experience are present; however, doing justice to these elements required the touch of a skilled director.
Stars: Janhavi Bansal, AB Vampking, Harleen Sethi
Rensil D'Silva—the man behind such "gems" as *Kurbaan*, *Ungli*, and *Dial 100*—is certainly not the right person if one is looking for subjectivity, style, or thought-provoking content. I do not mean to suggest that a director should be judged solely by past work or that they cannot evolve in the future. One need only look at Anubhav Sinha: who would have ever imagined that the man responsible for duds like *Cash*, *Tum Bin 2*, and *Ra.One* would mature into an artist capable of such powerful expression in films like *Mulk*, *Thappad*, *Bheed*, and *Assi*?
That is why, regardless of what trailers or promotional campaigns might say, I always approach a film or series hoping to find at least one surprise. Yet, with productions like *Shaque*, directors of D'Silva's caliber usually leave me heartbroken and deeply disappointed. Perhaps the title is trying to tell me something; maybe I should be more suspicious. Capturing madness on screen is no easy task, and most directors end up showing something that borders on the ridiculous. D'Silva achieves a similar effect in *Shaque*.
The director uses Anvita's (Parineeti Chopra) mental health struggles to create imagery—such as a baby's hand emerging from a cake or a woman's hand being severed by an axe—intended to evoke nightmares; in reality, however, they merely suggest a director exploiting a plot element simply to showcase "shocking visuals." In one scene, the lighting shifts from red to blue. In another, Anvita stumbles upon an animal carcass arranged as part of a witchcraft ritual. There are things Anvita isn't actually hallucinating; someone very close to her is playing tricks on her.
This gives D'Silva the chance to blur the lines between reality and fiction—a task at which he fails miserably, of course. Some of the blame also lies with Chopra, whose performance is unconvincing during these mental episodes. Her acting—marked by exaggerated gestures like flaring her nostrils—comes across in a way that screams "I am acting." Chopra struggles even in simple situations, such as when she has to sit in a chair and listen to her best friend's (Harleen Sethi) confession. Instead of appearing like a grieving mother, she projects the image of a psychopath on the verge of becoming a deranged serial killer. Her attempt to forcibly obtain a DNA sample from a child creates a sense of discomfort while simultaneously provoking involuntary laughter.
Perhaps the most important question to ask is this: does D'Silva himself know what he wants? I don't mind that Madhu's (Soni Razdan) blind faith in a *baba* (guru) serves as a critique of the widespread reliance on false spiritual leaders and gurus. However, claiming that *Shaque* meaningfully addresses the issue of superstition would be absurd, given that the series contradicts itself by placing its trust in—and validating as true—predictions made via tarot cards. Was D'Silva blindfolded during the scripting and filming stages? It gives the impression that he never actually saw what he was directing.
Or perhaps he realized the failure he had created and, to mask its flaws, decided to titillate the audience with scenes like the one where Shreya (played by Sethi) and Alok (Anvita's husband, played by Tahir Raj Bhasin) share a passionate kiss upstairs, while their respective spouses chat with guests in a downstairs room. When in doubt, nothing beats stimulating the viewer with transgressive sex so that hormones cloud their judgment; after all, sex sells.
Yet, *Shaque* unfolds in such a routine manner that I doubt anyone would feel truly aroused by that tepid kiss. Even scenes that ought to be brimming with drama—such as the one where Anvita accuses Sakshi (Jennifer Winget) of stealing her baby during a birthday party—fail to pack a punch; instead, they fall flat.

Comments
Post a Comment