Serial killers and murderers have fascinated storytellers and audiences across all entertainment mediums for generations. If we think about it, especially considering it's a theme explored in Fugue State 1986, some of the classic detective stories we read as children, written by Arthur Conan Doyle, Satyajit Ray, or Agatha Christie, dealt with rather gruesome murders. Since we weren't traumatized by them, we can say that reading them was fine, but the truth is, we've all consumed narratives centered on death from a very young age.
However, there's something about the analysis and fictionalization of real-life incidents through books, films, and television series that has always bothered me, especially if they don't directly condemn the criminal in question and instead offer something superficial like, "Oh, he was just a little misunderstood by society." And no one has done this kind of nonsense more than Ryan Murphy with his series Monster. Given how popular this franchise has been, I suppose other storytellers are taking inspiration from Murphy, and the results are just as disturbing as his series.
Stars: Andrés Parra, José Restrepo, Jorge Enrique Abello
Ana María Parra's Fugue State 1986, based on Mario Mendoza's Satanás, begins with a man named Jeremías massacring the staff and customers of the San Marzino restaurant and supposedly committing suicide or being killed by law enforcement shortly afterward. The series then focuses on León, who learns what his friend Jeremías has done.
All the evidence points to León knowing that Jeremías was going to do something like this. Why didn't he do anything to stop him? Was he an accomplice to Jeremías in this mission? And more importantly, why doesn't he remember anything about the night the terrible incident occurred? Well, that's because he suffers from dissociative amnesia. But that's not enough to clear his name, and with Jeremías dead, the police might arrest León to assure the public that they've made significant progress in the case. That's where Indira comes in. She's a disgraced forensic expert working as a taxi driver who occasionally helps her police officer friend, Mario, with minor cases. She takes a particular interest in Leon, and the journey she embarks on with him leads her to dark and disturbing places.
I'm not kidding when I say that after spending over six hours "developing" a fictionalized version of a real-life mass murderer who exhibits pedophilic, misogynistic, and frankly satanic tendencies, when Leon and Indira said there's no concrete explanation for why he was so evil, my jaw almost hit the floor. And I don't mean that in a good way. I was genuinely shocked that, for some reason, the writers of Fugue State 1986 tried to place Jeremias in this morally ambiguous space, even though they had gone to great lengths to portray him as the embodiment of evil.
Either they're too weak to take a stance, or they're trying too hard to emulate Ryan Murphy and his team, who have gained immense popularity for presenting some of the most morally reprehensible figures in human history as outcasts who were judged too harshly. Whatever the case, it's disgusting. The only thing worse than the way the writers handle the themes and historical references is the non-linear narrative. I don't know who has convinced all these Netflix show creators—perhaps Christopher Nolan—that intricate storytelling can create the illusion of complexity, but it clearly doesn't work anymore. If your story lacks substance and depth, no amount of time jumps will make it interesting.
Ryan Murphy's influence on Fugue State 1986 isn't limited to the distortion of facts (in the name of entertainment); its visuals and stylistic choices also emulate the master's shows. There are these unpredictable bursts of fetishization and objectification of certain characters that come out of nowhere and leave a sour taste in your mouth. Fortunately, thanks to those moments, you can question the intention behind this whole project.
That is, any sensible person would instantly criticize the objective of a heavily fictionalized biopic of an individual as dangerous as Campo Elías Delgado. But since media literacy is at an all-time low, I think these kinds of moments of frankness are necessary to pause and consider what series like this are trying to achieve. If all of this doesn't ruin your viewing experience, I'm sure the pacing will drive you crazy. I don't know if I can entirely blame the series creators, because Netflix wants more series and fewer films. Therefore, stories that barely warrant a feature film are artificially stretched out into these episodic series. Consequently, even if the directors and editors detect the repetitiveness of the narrative, which is mainly due to the inherent limitations of the format, they are forced to continue.
Andrés Parra, José Restrepo, and Carolina Gómez carry the weight of Fugue State 1986 on their shoulders. There's no doubt they are incredibly talented actors. But it seems that, in their minds, they are participating in three completely different series. I don't know if it's due to the script, the direction, or the actors' artistic choices; however, the tonal contrast I experienced with the three of them was disconcerting.
Parra, in an attempt to make Jeremías as awkward and strange as possible, gives the impression of being in one of those absurd political satires. Gómez, with her exaggerated eye movements and theatrical gestures while smoking, turns Indira into a parody of fictional detectives from the 1950s. Restrepo is the only one whose performance is relatively realistic, which, obviously, makes Leon somewhat more believable. Consuelo Luzardo, Camila Jurado, Álvaro Bayona, Juan Sebastián Calero, Paulina Díazgranadoz, César Mora, and the rest of the supporting cast fulfill their roles.
None of them are allowed to do anything that would make their character memorable. So I don't think I can criticize their talent. All that being said, do I recommend watching the series? Hmm... no. I don't think we need more series and movies about mass murders and serial killers, especially if they follow the style popularized by Ryan Murphy, because it's evident that society is drawing the wrong conclusions from them. If you want information, it's available in the news; read it. Fictionalized and sensationalized versions of these kinds of incidents are not the right way to learn about the darkest chapters of human history.

Comments
Post a Comment