Mr. and Mrs. Murder, the four-part docuseries, tells the story of an interesting case that occurred in 2000. It was one of those rare occasions when kind-hearted people took it upon themselves to uncover the truth and ensure the victims received justice. Typically, in criminal cases, if the perpetrator isn't caught early, it's impossible to convict. But this case defied all odds, and while some questions remained forever unanswered, the main perpetrators were imprisoned, even two decades after the crime. So, let's find out what happened in the case and how authorities uncovered the truth.
Jerry Michael “Mike” Williams, a resident of Bradfordville, Tallahassee, disappeared on the morning of December 16, 2000. He had apparently gone hunting near Lake Seminole with his childhood best friend, Brian Winchester, and no one had heard from him since. That morning, Brian's wife, Kathy, noticed he was quite tired upon his return. He didn't specify whether he had met Mike that morning, and although Kathy felt he was behaving strangely, she didn't ask him anything.
Stars: Kathy Thomas, Jennifer Winchester, Scott Dungey
Cheryl, Mike's mother, thought her son would return sooner or later, but he didn't. The strangest thing was that, apart from Cheryl and Kathy, no one seemed very interested in looking for the man. Kathy didn't understand why Denise (Mike's wife) was behaving this way and why even her husband seemed so uninterested in finding his best friend. At first, Mike's friends and family felt they probably weren't capable of processing it all, so they gave them the benefit of the doubt.
Mike, Brian, Denise, and Kathy had known each other since they were children. They had gone to school together, and their lives were practically a fantasy. They supported each other through every important stage of their lives, and watching each other reach adulthood and fulfill their dreams felt surreal. Kathy still remembered how happy Mike was when he found out he had become an uncle. But over time, things became a little complicated between the four of them. Kathy gave birth to their son, and it didn't take long for her to realize that Brian simply wasn't up to the responsibility.
Brian wanted to have fun; he didn't want to change his lifestyle, and sometimes he just left Kathy behind and did whatever he felt like. Kathy felt very lonely, raising her son and running the house alone. But she didn't say anything to Brian; she wanted him to live his life the way he wanted. But she soon realized that, after Mike disappeared, the distance between her and Brian grew even worse. He was often away from the house for long periods, even days, and Kathy had no idea where he was or what he was up to.
The search for Mike continued for many months, and one day his waders were found floating in the body of water where he had gone duck hunting. His hunting license was found in his pocket, and it became clear that Mike had met his fateful end. Aside from Kathy and Cheryl, no one believed the circumstances of Mike's disappearance to be suspicious. Whenever an accident like this occurred in the region, locals always found the victim's body; this was the first time anyone had any idea where the body had gone. Some believed alligators might have eaten the body, but something didn't add up.
There were a couple of things that made Kathy suspicious about Brian and Denise. First, Kathy received a letter from a man named Chuck Bunker almost three years after the incident with Mike, who claimed that Denise and Brian had something going on between them. Chuck wrote in his letter that he had dated Denise back in the day and ended up traveling to Atlanta with her. He said Brian arrived there unannounced and that he didn't like Denise being with another man. He stated in his letter that Brian and Denise were dating and that Denise found it fairly easy to get over her husband's death. Furthermore, Brian's father owned the Winchester Financial Group and helped Mike take out an insurance policy just days before his disappearance/death.
Apparently, Denise had asked Mike to increase the insurance coverage to $1.5 million, and Brian also endorsed it, telling her it would secure the family's future. After Mike's disappearance, it wasn't easy to convince the insurance company, as in cases of disappearance, especially if the body isn't found, there were many prerequisites to meet. Brian used his influence to get Denise the money, and Kathy noticed how hard he went to get it. In other words, he was a man who had no interest in his own family, but who was there for Denise and their daughter, Anslee. Kathy also found a receipt for some jewelry Brian had bought for Denise, and it was then that she became convinced they were having an affair.
Kathy felt unwanted; she felt abandoned, and realized it was best for them to separate. Brian was a cunning man and manipulated her to the point that she believed her marriage was ending because of him. All of these people had had very orthodox upbringings, and for them, divorce was a sin. But Kathy made a decision and ultimately filed for divorce. Brian managed to shape the narrative in a way that made him look like a victim. This gave her the freedom to do whatever she wanted, knowing society wouldn't judge her. So, approximately five years after Mike's disappearance, Denise and Brian went public with their relationship and married. Meanwhile, Cheryl continued to pressure and write to the relevant authorities to launch an investigation and find out what had happened to her son. She believed Mike couldn't have been in an accident. Her heart told her something wasn't right, as she had nightmares of her dead son screaming for help, even though everyone believed he had lost his mind.
Kathy distanced herself from Brian and Denise, but the fact that no one knew what had happened to Mike troubled her. Many people offered to help Cheryl and Kathy after learning their story. From Derrick Wester, an investigator with the Jackson County Sheriff's Office, to journalist Jennifer Portman, who worked at the Tallahassee Democrat, everyone did their best to bring the truth to light. Derrick Wester asked Brian to take a polygraph test, which he refused. Portman continued writing about Mike's disappearance in the hopes of sparking the authorities' interest and leading to a formal investigation.
An ATF special agent named Josey Visnovske decided to help Cheryl after hearing her story. Cheryl told him that Denise and Brian had a firearm in their possession that wasn't registered in their names. The presence of a missing gun gave Josey the excuse to question the parties involved, but even after her dedicated efforts, she made no progress. Brian and Denise decided to hand over the gun, and after that, Josey was unable to officially conduct the investigation. It is said that justice might be delayed, that the perpetrator might try to hide the truth, but it will come out sooner or later. Denise found it difficult to accept Brian's attitude. He was an extremely possessive man who constantly monitored her. Denise began to feel trapped in the relationship and decided to separate. Brian was a domineering and obsessive man, and he couldn't stand to see the love of his life walking away from him like that. In 2016, he forced her to return to him, and Denise became quite scared, as he was armed. She was sitting in her car when Brian sat next to her, and at that moment she realized he was capable of anything to get what he wanted. She went to the local police and told them she feared for her family's safety. After Denise reported it, Brian was arrested by authorities and charged with kidnapping.
That arrest gave authorities the opportunity to question Brian. Brian was sentenced to 20 years, but Kathy didn't like it. She knew that if he was sent to prison, no one would ever know what had happened to Mike. Kathy, in an attempt to pressure Denise for information, had begun speaking to her much more frequently over the past two years. She managed to make her believe that she still cared deeply about her. The special agent knew they would have no better opportunity to pressure Brian into revealing what had happened to Mike. On October 9, 2017, they decided to cut a deal with him; they told him that if he told them where Mike's body was buried, he would not be charged with the crime. I don't know what was going through Brian's mind, but he ultimately decided to reveal the truth.
In October 2017, Mike's remains were found about 98 kilometers from the Lake Seminole region, near Carr Lake. The postmortem report made it clear that he had been murdered, not killed in an accident. A mother who waited 17 years made it clear to the world that she wasn't crazy; that she wasn't wrong to believe something bad had happened to her son. The world didn't take her seriously, and the authorities let her down, but she persisted. I believe the love she felt for her son became the driving force that drove her to fight against everything and not be swayed by the constant neglect and disappointment she received.
Mike's body was found, but no one was charged with his murder. It sounds strange, but that's how legal systems work. The officers had reached an agreement with Brian, so even if he pleaded guilty in court, he couldn't be charged with the crime. But Brian implicated Denise and said that, although she didn't murder Mike, it was her master plan that he carried out. Denise was summoned for questioning, and Brian recounted the horrific details of that fateful day before the full court. He recounted how he pushed his best friend off the boat, then surrounded him and shot him in the head. He testified that he pulled his body from the shore and buried it where no one would find it.
Brian collapsed several times, likely aware that his sins would not be forgiven. Denise was charged with first-degree murder and also conspiracy with Brian. But in 2020, the conviction was overturned because, in reality, the evidence was merely circumstantial. Ultimately, she was charged with conspiracy to commit first-degree murder, but not with actually committing murder. So, the irony was that, even after she confessed everything, no one was charged with Mike's murder.
As mentioned above, Brian received a 20-year sentence, while Denise received 30. Some still believe that not everything related to the case was revealed and that Brian and Denise were still hiding certain facts. Mr. and Mrs. Murder mentioned that Brian couldn't have carried the body alone, dug a hole, and buried it. Kathy believes there were more people involved with Brian. My heart goes out to Brian and Denise's children, who will have to endure the trauma their entire lives. They suffered through no fault of their own. I don't believe what Brian felt for Denise was love. It was pure obsession and lust, to a degree. The whole truth will probably never be known, but at least a mother who waited two decades was able to close the chapter, although I don't think her wound...
Comments
Post a Comment