The brilliance of Rumaan Alam’s novel “Leave the World Behind,” published in 2020 at a time when apocalyptic themes seemed eerily prophetic, lies in its deliberate omission. The narrative unfolds with an impending catastrophe and involves a group of New Yorkers vacationing in a remote location. Surprisingly, the novel never reveals the cause of the calamity, leaving readers with a lingering sense of unease.
The film adaptation, directed by “Mr. Robot creator Sam Esmail retains this lingering concern, but the reasons are clearly different. Starring Julia Roberts and Ethan Hawke as Amanda and Clay Sandford, the film features an advertising executive and her teacher husband seeking a respite from urban life. Her retreat takes an unexpected turn when a mysterious blackout interrupts her idyllic getaway.
Director: Sam Esmail
Writers: Rumaan Alam, Sam Esmail
Stars: Julia Roberts, Mahershala Ali, Ethan Hawke
As the narrative unfolds, the arrival of a man (Mahershala Ali) and his daughter (Myha'la) who claim ownership of the house adds a layer of tension. The film, however, takes a divergent path from the subtle approach of the novel. Instead of allowing ambiguity to prevail, Esmail bombards the audience with a multitude of social issues that could lead to an apocalypse.
In contrast to the novel's overt exploration, the film lists a long list of potential threats, ranging from racial tensions and class divisions to conspiracy theories and technological traps. The narrative loses its nuance and becomes an unsparing portrait of everything that is wrong with America, presented with such force that it seems destined to provoke agreement rather than contemplation.
The film's attempt to cover a broad spectrum of social issues, along with open dialogue and visual choices, dilutes the narrative tension. The characters, initially on the brink of an unknown crisis, succumb to a sense of passivity, reflecting the audience's disconnection. The film lacks the careful restraint necessary to make the audience introspective, opting instead for an overwhelming barrage of social criticism.
As the cast, made up of accomplished actors, struggles to find their place in the discordant narrative, the film fails to strike the delicate balance between horror and discomfort. Overwrought dialogue and flashy camerawork choices contribute to a disjointed experience, leaving characters seemingly stranded in a narrative that should have evoked more fear or subtlety. Ultimately, the film fails to convey the haunting brilliance of its literary source.
Comments
Post a Comment