It Was Just an Accident, directed by Jafar Panahi, has garnered worldwide acclaim and received the Palme d'Or at the 2025 Cannes Film Festival. With a minimalist and seemingly simple format, the film begins with a discreet roadside incident, but what unfolds is much more than a revenge story: it is an in-depth exploration of truth, illusion, repressed rage, and the echoes of collective trauma.
Panahi, as always, avoids explicit exposition and invites the viewer on an inner journey, guided by deeply wounded yet still restless characters; characters who, to his credit, are masterfully developed, each embodying a fractured dimension of contemporary Iranian society. However, the viewing experience, especially in the first fifteen minutes, is anything but easy.
Director: Jafar Panahi
Writer: Jafar Panahi
Stars: Vahid Mobasseri, Mariam Afshari, Ebrahim Azizi
The film begins ambiguously, with minimal context and a slow pace that disorients the viewer. Even seasoned international audiences may wonder why they should remain engaged, unless they trust the director's prestige or the awards he has received.
Formally, the film presents a somewhat fresh structure, with occasional moments of dark humor. However, the acting, especially in scenes of great emotional intensity, lacks consistency and depth at times, occasionally undermining the emotional weight the story aims to convey. These flaws in execution cause emotional connections to be lost where the film clearly intends to strike a chord.
While the film ostensibly critiques violence and seeks justice and moral clarity, its focus on a single "culprit," rather than addressing the systemic and institutional apparatus of repression, makes its perspective surprisingly aligned with a refined version of reformist rhetoric. This softened, left-leaning moralism elides the major political upheavals of Iran's recent history, particularly the 2022 "Women, Life, Freedom" movement, and replaces structural critique with a narrowly personalized narrative. In doing so, it risks creating an unintentional sense of appeasement with the status quo for international audiences.
What accentuates this sense of ambiguity in a parallel world beyond the cinema is the fact that the cast and crew of this "clandestine and unauthorized film" have returned to Iran without consequences, something that remains a distant dream for many independent artists, journalists, and political dissidents in exile. This contrast raises a troubling question: does the film, consciously or unconsciously, offer a palatable narrative of pain, more suited to international festivals than to confronting the deeper truths of repression?
"It Was Just an Accident" is bold in form, but cautious at heart. It reveals fragments of truth with cinematic mastery, but avoids addressing the roots of the trauma it portrays. For international audiences, it may prove emotionally shocking and thought-provoking. But for Iranian viewers, the film is less a mirror than a carefully cropped reflection, diluted, fragmented, and ultimately incomplete in its portrayal of wounds that are still very much alive.
Comments
Post a Comment