I went into Same Day with Someone expecting something tender, a little predictable, maybe a few tears, but hoping for something new in the time-loop genre. For the most part, the film offers charm and also irritation. It's not great, but it has enough personality and heart to make me glad I saw it. Mesa (played by Jarinporn Joonkiat) is well-positioned: she has control, prestige, and an organized life.
Then disaster strikes. On August 8, everything that can go wrong does: the priceless artifact she's supposed to preserve is destroyed, her fiancé calls off the wedding, and her identity is shaken. Then the time loop kicks in, and we find ourselves on the same day again and again. The first loops are frantic, sometimes unpleasant, but there's an arc: Mesa is forced to abandon perfectionism and delve into empathy.
Directors: Rangsima Aukkarawiwat, Yanyong Kuruangkura
Stars: Grégory Matthias Garcia, Jarinporn Joonkiat, Metinee Kingpayome
What I liked: The film makes good use of the time loop device. Rather than simply mocking repetition, the film invites Mesa to see people she's ignored: her assistant Ning, her friend Ben. The way she insists on repairing the artifact and then focuses on helping Ning is its strongest point. The unexpected twist of Ben also being trapped, and of Mesa's journey not being solely about herself, gives the film great emotional impact. The scene in which she saves Ning (from a suicide attempt), rather than focusing solely on her own failures, gives the film its emotional denouement. The ending, where Mesa finally wakes up to a new day after giving up trying to control everything and starting to care about others, is satisfying.
Furthermore, the actors do an excellent job. Jarinporn Joonkiat carries Mesa's transformation with believability; the supporting cast, especially Ning and Ben, helps ground the story. Visually, the film is pleasing: museum halls, display cases of artifacts, temples, well-lit interiors, and elegant dresses. The fashion, lighting, and overall aesthetic work: it feels polished, which helps sell the more magical and romantic parts. Now, what didn't work so well: about 60% of my complaints. First: the pacing. Repetition is inherent to time loops, but Same Day with Someone drags on too long in many of the loops, not providing enough new texture.
Some loops feel like padding. One begins to wonder if the film is repeating itself to emphasize something or simply because it needs to fill the footage. Sometimes, the comedy tries too hard; reactions are exaggerated to elicit laughs so often that they border on the cartoonish, undermining the emotional truth of the more serious moments. The humor is uneven: sometimes it's sweet and earned; sometimes it feels forced.
Furthermore, Mesa's character is presented early on as a kind of "rich girl who has everything," to the point that her initial happiness feels unmistakable, even superficial. The film attempts to correct that through the disaster loop, but I sensed a certain tension: does it judge her too harshly, or does it try to make us feel bad for her without showing enough flaws early on to make the growth seem earned? Relatedly, the twist/revelation about Ning's background, the suicide case, etc., feels a bit sudden. It's important and poignant, but the introduction could have been more subtle or better anticipated. The change in motivation at the end of the film (to save someone else, not just herself) is good, but I think more setup would have made it more impactful.
There are moments when the romantic subplot (with Ben) seems to sigh, "Please give me something new," but instead delivers familiar beats: wish lists, confessions of feelings, that "maybe I'm using it to escape this loop" dialogue. These are familiar clichés. The film leans into them too easily. The ending is emotionally satisfying, but narratively somewhat tidy—too tidy. It asks us to accept his inner growth, and we do, but it glosses over some of the more unpleasant aspects (his own vanity, his failures) too quickly.
Another problem: the tonal shifts. The film strives for both romantic comedy and drama, conflict and introspection, humor and sadness. Sometimes the shifts work (especially when laughter follows a serious rhythm), but sometimes they clash. There's a loop where he tries multiple interventions to fix the appliance, explain things to his ex, get ready for the day; these are emotionally intense, and suddenly, comedic overkill. The transitions aren't always smooth. Because of this, the emotional stakes sometimes feel less significant than they should.
Despite its flaws, some moments work beautifully. Ning's rescue, the decision not just to escape but to make amends, the small moments of connection between Mesa and Ben (not just romantic gestures, but conversations, failures, confessions) bring warmth. Plus, the ending doesn't try to wrap everything up in a neat bow—with loss, with imperfect self-awareness—and that helps.
In short: Same Day with Someone doesn't reinvent the time-loop rom-com, but it plays it with enough feeling, humor, and occasional depth to make it a satisfying experience. If you're expecting something new in the genre, you'll be a little frustrated. But if you're looking for something heartwarming but still emotionally resonant, it delivers.
Comments
Post a Comment